The 4% rule and other fallacies of retirement planning

by Pop on February 24, 2010

Post image for The 4% rule and other fallacies of retirement planning

There’s a reason it’s called a retirement plan.

When you go to a financial planner or try out a quickie retirement calculator, it’ll often come back with a result that reads something like “Sticking to this allocation and savings plan, you’ll have a 90% chance of meeting your retirement needs.” A good financial planner will translate that for you, but a retirement calculator will just leave you hanging.

Is a 90% chance of meeting the target high? Is it low? Is a 10% chance of not meeting your target particularly high or low? Who knows?

The invention of the 4% rule

The “4% rule” is a common rule-of-thumb used to guide retirees when they’re getting ready to tap their nest egg. Let’s say you retired with $1 million. The rule says that in the first year, you can withdraw $40,000 (4% of $1 million). In year two, you can withdraw $40,000 plus a slight adjustment up for inflation. And so on.

You might not be as familiar with how that rule started. In 1998, a trio of professors at Trinity University penned a study looking at historical returns, withdrawal rates, and life expectancies. A table in the study broke down probabilities of success based on a 2% withdrawal rate, 3%, 4%, 5%, and so on. Four percent was simply the highest withdrawal rate where, most of the time, the probability to success was near 100%. So, all the media folks and financial planners turned it into mantra.

But was that what the professors intended? Not at all. In fact the study concludes: “For stock-dominated portfolios, withdrawal rates of 3% and 4% represent exceedingly conservative behavior.” Why did everybody gravitate to 4%? They were mesmerized by that 100% success rate.

How retirement really works

I wrote something recently for Consumerism Commentary that basically argued a 7% chance of not meeting your target is pretty high. I mean, it doesn’t seem high until you’re part of the 7%. Then you’ll wish you had invested as if you had a 99% or 100% success rate.

I still agree with what I wrote a little while ago, but I think I’m guilty of committing a wonkish mistake. You see, if you deal with these kinds of calculators and statistics and historical returns and probabilities long enough, you start to forget how people actually act. It’s like getting so caught up in batting averages and ERAs that you forget what a game looks like when it’s played.

I can set up a retirement plan for myself that the calculator says will give me a 100% chance of meeting my retirement income goal, but in the end, that ends up being a pretty useless exercise. Retirement calculators necessarily make you plan out 40 or 50 years of your life, but they don’t take into account humans’ abilities to adapt.

If someone saw their account balance drop dramatically in 2008, they probably ratcheted back their spending. On the other hand, if someone hits age 85 and still has millions in the bank, they probably decide to splurge a bit. We don’t set a plan at age 65 and blindly follow it as if nothing has changed for 30 years. That’s just stupid. (And that’s what a retirement calculator assumes.)

Your plan is more flexible than you think.

Where does that leave you and your retirement calculator? You could set up a plan that’s effective 100% of the time. Your calculator will tell you that you have to save a ton of money or work well beyond age 65. But in exchange, you’ll sacrifice a lot — maybe too much — of today’s standard of living to get those extra percentage points of certainty.

So next time I use a retirement calculator, I might not panic if it says I only have an 85% chance of meeting my retirement goal. Even when I enter retirement, I might try a 5% withdrawal rate, which according to the Trinity study, would give me an 80% chance of not outliving my money. As time goes on, I’ll adjust up or down depending on what life and the market throws at me.

After all, in 2020, I know I won’t look at the plan I wrote in 2010 and keep following it blindly. So why should I plan as if I will?

Share

{ 62 comments… read them below or add one }

Auto Glass Shop Near Lakewood Ranch August 4, 2024 at 6:15 pm

Consistently producing high-high quality content, like sending flowers just because. Thank you for The dedication.

car cal adas stand August 10, 2024 at 6:12 pm

The fresh insights were a breath of fresh air. Thank you for sharing The unique perspective.

adas car cal August 10, 2024 at 11:00 pm

I admire the way you tackled this hard to understand issue. Very enlightening!

Hugo Yakow August 25, 2024 at 6:36 pm

The Writing is like a secret garden, each post a path leading to new discoveries and delights.

carl cal experts September 8, 2024 at 11:25 pm

The work is both informative and thought-provoking. I’m really impressed by the high quality of The content.

carl cal experts September 9, 2024 at 7:30 pm

Thoughtful analysis that made me think, which is quite the feat these days.

car cal adas September 13, 2024 at 8:52 pm

Brilliant writing! You’ve perfectly captured the essence of the topic.

리니지 프리서버 구축 September 16, 2024 at 2:46 pm

How’s everything?Your blog post had me hooked from the start! Since stumbling upon your blog, I’ve been engrossed in your other articles. The captivating content you provide has left me yearning for more. I’ve subscribed to your RSS feed and am eagerly awaiting your future updates!Keep in touch.

리니지 프리서버 혼자하기 September 23, 2024 at 1:40 am

What’s up?I thoroughly enjoyed reading your blog post! Ever since I discovered your blog, I have been engrossed in your other articles. Your captivating content has left me eagerly awaiting more. I have subscribed to your RSS feed and am excitedly anticipating your future updates!Talk to you soon.

xz--dmeg:^ October 16, 2024 at 8:38 am

Hi thereWhile exploring a new website, we stumbled upon a webpage that instantly grabbed our interest. We are thoroughly impressed with what we have seen thus far and eagerly anticipate your future updates. We are excited to further explore your website and discover all the incredible features it has to offer.Take care.

xz--dmeg:^ October 16, 2024 at 9:23 am

How’ve you been?Your blog post immediately caught my attention! Since stumbling upon your blog, I have been engrossed in every article you’ve shared. The captivating content you provide has left me yearning for more. I’ve subscribed to your RSS feed and am eagerly awaiting your future updates!Godspeed.

xz--dmeg:^ October 17, 2024 at 6:50 am

GreetingsWhile exploring a new website, we stumbled upon a webpage that instantly grabbed our interest. We are thoroughly impressed with what we have seen so far and are eagerly anticipating your future updates. We are excited to further explore your website and discover all the incredible things it has to offer.Catch you later.

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: