And can I contradict myself in a week?
When I was in college, I dressed like a homeless person. Now, I dress like I’m in college. It’s not that I can’t afford nicer clothes. Thankfully I’m well beyond the “no money” years. It’s just that I never really “upgraded” to the stuff most of my peers are wearing nowadays.
So I should be patting myself on the back, right? Living like a poor person—when you’re not—is one of those tried and true personal finance adages that mark classics like The Millionaire Next Door. The millionaires live like they’re not rich. They buy used cars. They eat at home. Then they retire early or spend retirement travelling the world because they’ve saved so much gosh darn money.
But sometimes left out of the discussion of saving, is how much is too much when you’re retirement planning.
To take it to an extreme and keep things simple, let’s say we’ve got a 25-year old making $60,000. He’s totally bought into saving like a madman and maxes out a Roth IRA and a 401k every year until he retires. Based on one, mainstream retirement calculator, that would give him about $8,900 per year per month once he retired at age 66—almost two and a half times what he used to live on at age 65.
He could fund two of his retirements, and still have half a retirement left over. Should we celebrate that?
The concept of “consumption smoothing”
I think most people would say “No.” The 25-year-old self was cheated out of current pleasures…his trip to Norway, his “grown-up” clothes…that would have been perfectly fine for him to buy. Instead, his 80-year-old self either goes on a spending binge, leaves a large inheritance, or tries to pay off St. Peter.
Instead, many economists consider the ideal savings amount to be that which “smooths” your consumption over your lifetime. In short, you want your quality of life in your 60s and beyond to be about as high as it was in your 30s.
At some point and to make things simple, personal finance gurus started to back out savings targets—like 10% or 20%—that would achieve consumption smoothing as long as the stock market hit certain rates of return.
Laurence Kotlikoff, a Boston University economist, a few years ago took it so far as to create an extremely comprehensive retirement calculator, that can show you how much you should consume every year into and through retirement based on the assumptions you put in. (Here’s the more basic, free version.)
Can you save too much for retirement? Yes! But in personal finance circles, it’s generally not “cool” to spend. A recent Wall Street Journal column derided people who buy iPad 2s (or is it iPads 2?). The logic: It’s really costing you $2,000 since you could have invested it instead! By that logic, I should really feel bad about my $5 lunch today—that could have been $20, after inflation, in 2041. This year, I will blow $7,200 of my future money on lunch. I’m such a moron.
The columnist’s logic assigns little to no value to present enjoyment, in favor of future enjoyment. That makes no sense.
Don’t get me wrong, this doesn’t apply to most people. Most Americans will retire with little to no savings. And those people shouldn’t be buying iPads. But given that you’re reading this blog, I’m betting you’re putting at least a bit away already, or at least thinking about putting a bit away.
Throw uncertainty into the mix, and suddenly saving “too much” seems impossible.
The idea of consumption smoothing has a major flaw, of course: uncertainty. We don’t know what stocks will return over the next decades. We don’t know where tax rates will be or if we’ll be in a car accident or if the roof will need to be replaced, etc.
Or perhaps a more dire situation: Imagine you’re a 53-year old staring down the newly proposed Republican budget. In 12 years, you were expecting Medicare. Bzzzzz. Wrong. Maybe you could have seen some sort of Medicare reform coming, but you probably didn’t predict the fairly random age-55 cutoff that would probably allow you to save thousands in insurance costs if you had only been born in 1956.
There are two ways to react to that uncertainty: To save as much as you can in case a worst-case scenario comes along or to save for a best-guess scenario and risk having to cut consumption if the dice come up snake eyes.
I’m saving for a “best guess”, with the reasonable safety measures of a year-long emergency fund, an annuity, etc. Sure, fate could frown on me, but I’m not willing to make a guaranteed sacrifice of reasonable happinesses today just to prepare for a possibly scary future. There’s a chance, my 66-year old self might be unhappy with the current me, but he’s going to have to deal with it.
{ 92 comments… read them below or add one }
“$8,900 per year”
typo? “per month”?
Yup, I was born in 1957! OW!
I thought we had saved enough for retirement. As of yesterday- I am seriously considering returning to work.
I am a bit ticked that my brother, who has saved nothing, will receive Medicare fully- but I will not. So much for believing in the fairy tale!
You beat me to the punch! I was just working on a similar argument: http://messymatters.com/savings?secretpreview
The “you could’ve invested that” idiocy is very annoying. People need to grok the concept of future discounting.
I would rather save too much than not enough! I am enjoying my life too. We travel overseas every other year and a minor vacation every year. One of our minor vacations was a week in Vancouver, BC and 5 days in New Orleans, LA.
@Dangerman – Good catch, thanks!
@Janette – You can take solace in the fact that it’s nearly impossible to get anything huge done in Congress, especially with one this divided. By the time they pass something, even if that part stays in there, maybe you’ll have made it to 55!
@Daniel Reeves – Awesome to see someone using “grok” in a post and a comment. I wish there was a way to feel discounted future rewards in the same way we feel present rewards. Do you know if anybody’s studied extreme savers? I wonder what parts of their brains are firing when they think about a rich retirement versus a present-day iPad.
@krantcents – Agreed. I wasn’t meaning to bash savers! Balance is key.
@Pop: Some theories:
1. Their sense of self-worth is tied up with their bank balance.
2. They’re altruists with high value for leaving money for their heirs.
3. They’ve grokked the mathematics of compound interest but not the corresponding (roughly identical) mathematics of future discounting. So they really believe it’s crazy to spend $5 now that will eventually become hundreds of dollars if they invest it.
4. Plain old OCD? (Like maybe hyperfocus on their goal of retiring.)
@Daniel Reeves – I think that these were good comments. Especially the one about leaving money to heirs. Some people (and I don’t have any children) find that making the next generation better off than they are is a very noble goal.
@Pop – I’m glad you brought the uncertainty line in at the end. If it weren’t for uncertainty, we’d all know exactly how much we’d need to save for retirement to retire in 20XX. It’s one of the main drivers for me to “oversave” at this point in my life (I’m 32).
One final thing is that certain people (me) might find that their utility gained by saving $20 today is greater than the best possible purchase they could make. Do I want a picture frame? Sure. Can I maximize my utility somewhere else? For me, yeah, bank it.
I assume that my preferences will change as I age, but that’s my reason for saving right now. It makes me feel good. Even though it’s at a rate higher than I really need to. I can always choose to save less in the future, but I can never choose to save more in the past.
It depends on how much you want to be living it up during retirement.
I’d rather save more than enough than not save enough.
Seems that everyone is forgeting that saving now is based on earnings now.
My hubby and I are saving decently right now. 15% of our income, not counting an additional 4% each in 401k. now, we’re mostly able to do that and not sacrifice our lifestyle (we like to travel a couple times a year and go out to nice restaurants, etc.), by having bought a smaller, cheaper house than we could’ve afforded. I think the age of the mcmansion is over. we also did most of the remodeling ourselves and saved on remodel costs. I also am still driving a base-model car i bought 9 years ago, and paid off 4.5 years ago. If people really look at the things that eat up their disposable income (often large houses and new expensive cars), they will find ways to cut back in some areas, save more and still be ale to have fun. also, we’re saving a good amount b/c we don’t have kids yet but would like to sometime soon. When we do, i will be qitting my full-time job, so we’re anticipating our income to be considerably lower, at which point we may need some of those savings to actually pay bills. everyone is saving for a reason and yes, you have to have a good balance between saving too much and not enjoying your present day, or not saving enough to get by when you are old and frail.
@Pop and @Daniel Reeves: I think that Daniel in part has the idea, but I propose that reward has little to do with super savers compared to the negative pain of spending money.
Perhaps it is the case that they are simply so far down the cost-conscious spectrum that any expenditure feels like they are getting a bad deal, but they suck it up for the necessary expenses (e.g. food). For example, would you pay $50 for a banana from the grocery store tomorrow? Why not? Now imagine that you are someone that felt exactly that same way when the price of that banana is $0.50 cents instead of dollars.
Perhaps (especially looking at the now disappearing Great Depression generation, now reappearing anew from the Great Recession) the case is that the super savers have suffered some extreme poverty at some point to the extent that it affected their psyche and they are now terrified [consciously or not] of ever experiencing that again.
Perhaps the super savers in their 20s and 30s really are going to retire when they turn 35 or 40 in order to to participate in some leisure activity that they need to be physically healthy for (or by the time they have spent a decade not-spending find that they cannot break the habit).
I’m with Tim on this one. I probably qualify as a super saver at age 29. I bought a small house, drive a paid-off car, etc. Somewhere about 4 years ago saving just started to feel more pleasurable than spending. I still want things… But I’ve seen that wants are infinite. Kinda makes buying really cute new boots seem pointless. Your Money or Your Life was a big influence. I wonder sometimes if I’ll ever be able to turn off the saver instinct. Seems like a thin line between frugal and miser. The one area I really splurge is travel.
My parents gave me the best blueprint for retiring with enough money:
1. Take every retirement program you can whether offered by your workplace, association or the government (e.g. IRA)
2. Pay off your mortgage before you retire.
3. Pay off personal debt-such as credit cards!
4. Do not live beyond your means-ever.
It worked, even though I was in the arts and never really had anything like a steady income. Thanks, Mommy and Daddy.
Savings is a form of insurance. It is insurance against having your life blow-up if something bad happens. I was laid-off when I was 50 in an industry that is contracting significantly. That sucked. Trying to get a job or contract work is not going any better.
While working, I worked hard, enjoyed my job for the most part, saved a lot and invested reasonably well. By the way, to get better investment result than the vast majority of people is not hard or complicated.
Since my wife and I bought the insurance (saved a lot while working), we do not have to work another day. To tell you the truth though, I would rather be working.
I have never seen a retirement calculator that includes an option to have a major negative life event. Many of the people laid off recently that have been fortunate enough to find a job, have accepted jobs with incomes much lower than their previous one. Health issues can put a big hole in your savings in a hurry. By saving more now, you get to sleep better now and not be stressed out as much if things do go bad.
Great article Pop
Thanks for the great article Pop
, it is really true that we all must save for our retirement. I too started saving for my retirement from the last month. I know its too late, but before I was in huge debt and it can’t possible for me to save something for my future. I tried lot to get myself debt free, suddenly one day while surfing internet I came across to a Debt Consolidation Company, and believe me today I am debt free. Now I started saving for my retirement.
Saving money for retirement is altogether a debatable issue. It’s like you can’t have enough no matter how much you plan to save for the same. I feel a person should have a plenty amount of savings so that he/she can have a secured as well comfortable life post retirement. Thanks a lot for sharing this content with your readers.
Andrea Jones
Some people of the “herd” won’t want to get involved because by now many people are aware that not everything is what it seems. Believe it or not, many people are completely aware that “set-ups” are happening every day and all around. Not everyone is oblivious to the cultists of academe and their silly studies. Did you hear about those pigeons who found they could alter the behavior of lab technicians just by refusing corn pellets? Uh huh.
Hi, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!
Sweet internet site, super design, really clean and use friendly.
This web site is really a walk-through for all of the info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll definitely discover it.
Thank you for another wonderful post. Where else could anyone get that type of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I’m on the look for such information.
obviously like your web-site but you need to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth nevertheless I will certainly come back again.
As a Newbie, I am continuously exploring online for articles that can help me. Thank you
Hey very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I am happy to find so many useful info here in the post, we need develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .
Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an exceptionally marvellous opportunity to read articles and blog posts from this web site. It really is very superb plus packed with amusement for me personally and my office colleagues to visit your website really three times in 7 days to study the new things you have got. Of course, I’m just certainly motivated with the attractive tricks served by you. Certain 2 tips in this article are essentially the most effective I’ve ever had.
Hey very cool site!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I am happy to find a lot of useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .
I’ve recently started a site, the information you offer on this web site has helped me tremendously. Thanks for all of your time & work.
Hmm it looks like your blog ate my first comment (it was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I had written and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any recommendations for newbie blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.
Perfectly pent subject material, thankyou for information .
Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your content seem to be running off the screen in Internet explorer. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know. The layout look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon. Thanks
It’s really a great and useful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
A person essentially help to make seriously articles I would state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the research you made to make this particular publish amazing. Excellent job!
I appreciate your work, thankyou for all the good content.
I am glad to be a visitant of this pure weblog! , thanks for this rare info ! .
F*ckin’ tremendous things here. I am very glad to see your post. Thanks a lot and i’m looking forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a e-mail?
Hi! Someone in my Facebook group shared this website with us so I came to look it over. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Outstanding blog and brilliant design.
I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one nowadays..
This website can be a walk-via for all of the data you needed about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and also you’ll undoubtedly discover it.
Keep working ,great job!
Thank you for every other informative web site. The place else may just I get that type of info written in such an ideal approach? I have a undertaking that I am just now running on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such information.
My wife and i were absolutely thrilled Ervin managed to do his research through the precious recommendations he grabbed through your web site. It’s not at all simplistic to simply choose to be offering tactics which usually a number of people could have been selling. We do understand we now have the blog owner to be grateful to for that. The type of illustrations you have made, the simple blog navigation, the friendships your site make it possible to engender – it is many sensational, and it’s helping our son and our family believe that this article is entertaining, which is certainly exceptionally serious. Many thanks for the whole thing!
Thanks for the good writeup. It in fact used to be a enjoyment account it. Look advanced to more introduced agreeable from you! However, how could we keep up a correspondence?
Heya i am for the primary time here. I came across this board and I to find It really helpful & it helped me out much. I’m hoping to give something again and help others like you aided me.
Hi there, You’ve done an incredible job. I will certainly digg it and in my opinion recommend to my friends. I’m sure they’ll be benefited from this web site.
I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the layout of your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or two images. Maybe you could space it out better?
so much excellent info on here, : D.
I am forever thought about this, thanks for posting.
I have read a few good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much effort you put to make such a great informative site.